The Anglican Church in Rwanda is entering a new chapter of leadership as a new Archbishop prepares to take charge of a church facing a number of complex issues that will require lasting solutions.
Among the key challenges are governance concerns that emerged in the Diocese of Shyira, questions surrounding trust between church members and leaders, the management of church resources, as well as changes and divisions that continue to shape the wider Anglican Communion around the world.
The new Archbishop succeeds Archbishop Laurent Mbanda, who led the Anglican Church in Rwanda for several years and leaves behind unresolved governance issues that continue to attract attention.
Shyira: A Diocese That Has Been Without a Bishop
One of the most significant challenges awaiting the new Archbishop is the situation in the Diocese of Shyira, one of the major dioceses of the Anglican Church in Rwanda.
The issue intensified during the tenure of Bishop Samuel Mugisha Mugiraneza, who faced allegations relating to the governance and financial management of the diocese.
Mugisha was initially suspended from his leadership position before resigning as Bishop on November 29, 2024.
On January 21, 2025, Rwanda Investigation Bureau (RIB) arrested him and investigated him over offenses related to the management of church resources.
His case attracted considerable debate, particularly following conflicting reports regarding the court’s decision.
The Anglican Church in Rwanda later rejected reports that Mugisha had been acquitted, explaining instead that he had been sentenced to three years and six months in prison.
On appeal, the sentence was upheld, although a substantial portion of it was suspended, leading to Mugisha’s release after he had already spent sufficient time in prison.
However, the leadership crisis in the Diocese of Shyira did not end there.
The diocese is still awaiting the appointment of a new bishop.
In early 2026, the Shyira Synod had approved two candidates from whom the new bishop would be chosen.
However, the continued delay in appointing the bishop has raised questions about the reasons behind the delay and when the diocese will once again have a permanent leader.
The major challenge facing the new Archbishop in Shyira is therefore not simply finding Mugisha’s successor.
It is also about rebuilding trust that has been damaged between church leaders and members, as well as among different levels of the church’s leadership.
During the dispute, some church leaders and members expressed dissatisfaction with the way the matter was handled.
Some senior church leaders also criticized the manner in which the situation had been addressed.
The church leadership, on the other hand, maintained that the measures taken against Mugisha were intended to address governance and financial-management concerns and to ensure accountability.
The new Archbishop will therefore have to engage with the different sides, listen to their concerns and establish credible mechanisms for resolving disputes, rather than allowing governance problems to continue fueling divisions within the church.
Laurent Mbanda and the Leadership Legacy He Leaves Behind
Laurent Mbanda occupies a particular position in this story because, before becoming Archbishop, he served as Bishop of Shyira.
He was succeeded in Shyira by Samuel Mugisha and was leading the Anglican Church in Rwanda when tensions within the diocese intensified.
Some people have argued that the way the Mugisha issue was handled contributed to deepening divisions within the diocese.
However, these remain the views and allegations of some individuals, and they are not in themselves sufficient to conclude that Mbanda caused or orchestrated the problems.
The church leadership, for its part, has consistently maintained that the dispute was connected to governance, financial management and accountability.
The new Archbishop will therefore have to determine whether he can bring this chapter of conflict to an end and ensure that Shyira does not once again become a major source of internal controversy within the church.
Church Closures Are Another Challenge
Another issue the new Archbishop will inherit is the impact of the government’s inspection of places of worship in Rwanda.
In 2024, the government closed numerous worship facilities that did not meet various requirements, including building safety, hygiene, registration and other legal standards.
The inspections also affected Anglican congregations.
This could have consequences for the operations of churches, particularly in relation to places where worship and evangelism take place, church property, contributions from members, as well as the ability to pay staff and renovate church buildings.
The new Archbishop will therefore have to help the church continue complying with legal requirements while also addressing the condition of closed worship facilities so that they can be properly improved and, where permitted, resume serving congregations.
Rwanda’s Anglicans and the Wider Global Anglican Debate
The challenges facing the new Archbishop in Rwanda are not limited to the church’s internal affairs.
The wider Anglican Communion continues to experience major debates over theology, governance and issues concerning same-sex relationships.
Several African countries, including Rwanda, Uganda and Nigeria, have continued to support traditional teachings based on the Bible, while churches in some European and American countries have adopted different positions on some of these issues.
These differences have strengthened the voice of GAFCON, a global movement of Anglicans who support the preservation of traditional Anglican teaching.
Rwanda has also played a role in these debates, particularly through Laurent Mbanda’s involvement in GAFCON.
However, it would be an exaggeration to say that African Anglicans have already broken away from Canterbury.
Rather, there are significant disagreements and debates over the structure of the Anglican Communion and the role that the Archbishop of Canterbury should play within it.
The new Archbishop will therefore have to continue representing the teachings and interests of the Anglican Church in Rwanda while also navigating the changes and debates taking place within the global Anglican community.
Shyira Could Be the First and Biggest Test
Of all the challenges awaiting the new Archbishop, Shyira could prove to be the first and perhaps the most difficult test.
The diocese has spent a considerable period facing governance challenges. Its last bishop left office, was subsequently subjected to legal proceedings, and the diocese has yet to receive a new bishop.
What church members will be waiting for is therefore not simply the name of a new leader.
They will be looking for stability, reconciliation and leadership capable of restoring their trust.
The new Archbishop will also have to demonstrate that a change in leadership is not simply about replacing one person with another, but represents an opportunity to address long-standing problems that have affected the unity and effective functioning of the church.
The central question will be:
Can the new Archbishop restore stability in Shyira, rebuild trust between church members and leaders, improve the governance and management of church resources, and give Rwanda a strong voice amid the major changes taking place within the global Anglican Communion?
The answer to that question will determine whether the Anglican Church in Rwanda has merely entered a new leadership era—or whether it is also entering a new period defined by reconciliation, renewed trust and improved governance.
By Mwizerwa Ally
Rwandatribune.rw